The Content of Our Character: Wisdom from Dr. Martin Luther King.

Dr. Martin Luther is one of the giants of our lifetime.

Some sentences refuse to grow old.

They survive decades of political arguments, social upheaval, cultural change and our seemingly endless national talent for disagreeing with one another.

One of the most enduring came from Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., who dreamed of a nation in which his children would not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character.

It sounds beautifully simple.

Living it is considerably harder.

When Justice Samuel Alito invoked that principle, he brought an old and enormously important American question back into the spotlight: What does it really mean to treat people equally?

That question deserves more than another shouting match.

It deserves some thought.

A Dream Bigger Than a Slogan

Dr. King wasn't asking Americans merely to become more polite.

He wasn't suggesting that we pretend race never existed or that generations of racial injustice could simply be erased by declaring everyone equal.

His dream was far more demanding.

It challenged America to live up to its own ideals.

Imagine the radical simplicity of the proposition: Look at the human being standing in front of you.

Who is this person?

What does she believe?

How does he treat other people?

Is this individual honest, compassionate, responsible, courageous and fair?

Those are questions about character.

Race, meanwhile, tells us remarkably little about any of those things.

You cannot determine honesty from pigmentation.

You cannot measure kindness from ancestry.

You cannot calculate intelligence from ethnicity.

And courage certainly doesn't arrive with a racial identification card.

Human beings are more complicated than categories.

Thank goodness for that.

 

But Here's Where Things Get Complicated

Americans love simple principles right up until we have to apply them to complicated situations.

"Judge people as individuals" sounds straightforward.

But history doesn't disappear simply because we would prefer to move forward.

Racial discrimination was real. Segregation was real. Barriers to housing, education, voting, employment and opportunity were real.

The effects of injustice can linger long after a law changes.

So we face two moral responsibilities that can sometimes feel as if they are pulling us in opposite directions.

First, we should never reduce an individual to his or her racial identity.

Second, we should never use individualism as an excuse to ignore discrimination when it exists.

Those ideas don't have to be enemies.

In fact, I think we need both.

 

Character Is Personal

One of the dangers of our increasingly tribal culture is the temptation to assume we know someone once we know which group supposedly contains them.

Race.

Religion.

Political party.

Age.

Gender.

Neighborhood.

Even what television network somebody watches can apparently determine whether we're expected to invite them to Thanksgiving.

It's getting ridiculous.

Character requires something much more difficult: actually getting to know people.

A person can belong to a group without being defined by every assumption attached to that group.

That's particularly important for those of us old enough to remember earlier eras.

Baby Boomers have watched enormous changes in American attitudes toward race during our lifetimes. Many of us remember segregation, the civil rights movement and battles over equality that younger generations encountered primarily in textbooks.

We also know progress didn't happen magically.

People marched.

People voted.

People challenged institutions.

People changed laws.

And, perhaps most importantly, people changed minds.

 

 

Equality Isn't Selective

There's another uncomfortable part of believing in equality.

You don't get to apply it only when it benefits people you agree with.

If race shouldn't determine someone's worth, then that standard must apply universally.

If discrimination is wrong, it remains wrong when the person being discriminated against is unpopular.

If dignity belongs to everyone, it also belongs to people whose politics make you want to throw a shoe at the television.

Principles become principles precisely when they're inconvenient.

Otherwise they're preferences.

That's why character remains such a powerful standard.

Character asks what you actually do.

Are you truthful when lying would be easier?

Do you defend someone who isn't in the room?

Do you admit when you're wrong?

Do you treat the waiter with the same respect you give the CEO?

Do you listen to people whose experiences differ from yours?

That's character.

And none of it appears on a census form.

 

Colorblind Doesn't Have to Mean History-Blind

There is an important distinction worth making.

Wanting individuals to be treated without racial prejudice does not require pretending racial injustice never happened.

We can remember history without sentencing every living person to remain trapped inside it.

We can recognize discrimination while still believing individuals deserve to be evaluated individually.

We can acknowledge that communities have experienced different obstacles without assuming everyone within those communities thinks alike.

That balance may not fit neatly onto a bumper sticker.

Too bad.

Real life rarely does.

 

 

What Would Dr. King's Challenge Mean at the Kitchen Table?

Perhaps the most productive way to approach the famous principle isn't to ask what Washington should do.

Start smaller.

Start with ourselves.

When somebody walks into the room, what assumptions do we make?

When someone disagrees with us, do we become curious or immediately assign them to the enemy camp?

Do we judge an individual based on what that person has actually said and done, or based on what people who look like them supposedly believe?

Those questions make the issue personal.

And that's where character lives.

Not in speeches.

Not in hashtags.

Not in political slogans.

In choices.

The Audacious Idea: See the Person

Maybe genuine progress requires having the audacity to look past categories without pretending categories have never mattered.

See history.

See injustice when it exists.

But above all, see the human being.

That person has hopes, failures, contradictions, talents, fears and dreams that no demographic box could possibly contain.

We have become extraordinarily skilled at sorting ourselves.

Perhaps it's time to become better at knowing one another.

Dr. King's vision remains powerful because it asks something simultaneously simple and difficult of us: Let character matter more than appearance.

Not because race has never mattered in American history.

But because our ultimate destination should be a society in which race does not determine the value, opportunity or dignity of an individual.

We're clearly not finished getting there.

Perhaps we never completely will be.

But the destination still matters.

And after all these years, the question isn't simply whether we can quote Dr. King.

It's whether we're willing to practice the principle when the person standing in front of us is someone we don't understand, don't agree with or don't particularly like.

That is when character really counts.

 


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.


Join our newsletter

Get exclusive offers, updates, and inspiration delivered to your inbox
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime.